Sunday, March 30, 2008

Why hiking is less fun when you can't get lost and die

Going hiking in Hong Kong is a very pleasant experience. This weekend, for example, we caught the MTR just 30 minutes away, then caught a bus to the beginning of the well marked trail. Along the way of the 4 hour trail there are benches and rubbish bins, emergency telephones, and in the middle of this particular hike, a shop where you can stop for noodles and sweet tofu. At the end of the hike there is even a drink machine to get water.


This is different from hiking in Australia. I contrast my nice hike this weekend with a day hike in S.E. Queensland where we firstly woke up at 4 am and drove 2 and a half hours to get to Mt Barney, then started the hike, got lost and spent the night in the cold. It was a far less pleasant experience.
Like a lot of other things in Hong Kong, the natural environment, specifically the country parks, also seem convenient, orderly, and subject to human control.

Speaking in wanky philosophical terms, I think the approach to hiking in Hong Kong is an example of an instrumental view of nature. Put simply, the mountains in the new territories are good for weekend walks, therefore they have value to us. When put in the context of recreation, this idea can become closely linked with consumerism, or even the commodification of nature. In Hong Kong’s country parks you can consume a nature experience as easily as consuming iced tea and fish balls from the seven eleven.

The opposite view is to see nature as having intrinsic value: whether we can get something out of the mountains or not, they should be respected and protected. According to environmental philosophers such as Arne Naess, this approach not only works out better for the natural environment, but it is a fundamental part of human spirituality. This approach aims to challenge the traditional (mainly western) dichotomy of man and nature as being two separate things.
The main difference is who is in control. When you start a day hike in many national parks (I’m thinking Mt Warning, or Mt Barney because you always hear stories of accidents in these places) the hiker is in a position where they have to submit to the surrounding environment. In Hong Kong, while of course accidents still happen, it is clear that people have gone to great lengths to control the experience.
If most people’s interaction with nature through hiking is an extension of a consumer lifestyle it doesn’t necessarily lead to a reevaluation of a person’s place in the wider environment, or instill a greater respect for nature.

I wonder how much this affects people’s environmental ethics in their daily lives.


3 comments:

Anonymous said...

My philosophical brain is hurting after reading this. Sorry!

Your mother

Anonymous said...

I like all the pictures - short attention span.

Jessie said...

a most scintillating reflection, fiona. I like the metaphysical connection between the consumerist and nature.

I might be getting a pet rabbit - see: in England, man and nature combine peacefully when you buy your bit of nature from a breeder.